Offer approval workflow: follow one offer through every set of hands

The offer on the desk
Meet the offer. It belongs to a mid-level operations role, it has a candidate's name at the top, and right now it is unsigned, unbudgeted in its final form, and one misunderstanding away from going wrong. SHRM describes the job offer as one of HR's most critical operational duties, because the offer is what initiates the employee's legal employment relationship with the organization — and it is also the last point at which the candidate can negotiate terms before joining. That dual nature is why an offer never travels alone. It moves through a chain of owners, each of whom checks something different, and each of whom can send it back. What follows is that chain, stage by stage, with the names of the people who usually hold each gate. Company sizes and industries rearrange the gates, and some employers merge two of them into one desk, but the checks themselves are remarkably stable.
Handoff one: the requisition underneath it all
Owner: the hiring manager who opened the role, with HR confirming the requisition is live.
Before anyone approves an offer, someone has to confirm there is an approved job to offer. The offer inherits its title, level, location and pay band from the requisition, so the first check is backward-looking: does this offer match the requisition that was signed off when the role was opened? In US federal hiring, the equivalent step is explicit — the US Office of Personnel Management's hiring process model has the manager create a Request for Personnel Action (the SF-52) to fill the job and obtain approval of it before the process moves on. Private employers rarely use that form, but the logic is identical: no approved request, no offer.
What bounces it back: a requisition that was closed, frozen, or approved for a different level or location than the one on the offer. The paper trail this stage leaves is the requisition record itself — the offer file should carry its identifier, so anyone auditing later can trace the hire to the approved headcount.
Handoff two: the decision note
Owner: the hiring manager, with the interview panel's input already recorded.
The second gate is the selection decision. The hiring manager states, in writing, who was chosen and why, against the criteria the role was opened with. This looks like a formality, but it does real work: it is the employer's contemporaneous record that the choice was made on job-related grounds, created at the moment of decision rather than reconstructed later. If your structured interview process produced scorecards or ratings, they belong in the same packet, and this is the stage where they get attached.
What bounces it back: a decision note that names a candidate the panel did not evaluate, or criteria that appear nowhere in the job description — both are signs the packet was assembled after the fact. The paper trail is the signed decision record plus the evaluation materials it references.
Handoff three: the compensation check
Owner: HR, usually a recruiter or HR business partner who owns the pay band.
Here the numbers get checked against two things: the approved salary range for the role, and internal equity — what people already doing comparable work at the company are paid. SHRM's guidance on making offers stresses that the salary and benefits package should be decided earlier in the recruitment process, often as early as the point where the need for the position is established, precisely so this stage is a verification rather than a negotiation with your own budget. The same guidance warns that an offer has to stay within the limits and the fair practices of the company, because employees compare pay, and an outlier offer becomes next quarter's equity complaint.
What bounces it back: a base salary above the band maximum, a signing bonus nobody budgeted, or terms — extra vacation, a company vehicle, equipment — that were promised in conversation but never costed. The paper trail is the compensation worksheet or its equivalent in the applicant tracking system, showing the band, the proposed figure's position in it, and who verified both.
Handoff four: the budget sign-off
Owner: finance, or the budget holder for the department, depending on how the company routes spend.
Finance does not care who the candidate is. Finance checks three things: that the headcount is funded, that the total cost of the package — salary plus bonus, benefits load and any one-time payments — fits the department budget for the period, and that the start date lands in the right budget window. This is the gate where an offer approved in principle at the start of a quarter can stall at the end of one, which is why experienced recruiters get this signature before anyone calls the candidate.
What bounces it back: an unbudgeted role, a package whose total cost exceeds the approved figure even though the salary alone fits, or a start date that pushes cost into a closed period. The paper trail is a dated budget approval tied to the requisition — an approver name and a date, not a verbal "sounds fine."
Handoff five: the letter review
Owner: HR, checking the document itself; legal counsel joins for senior or nonstandard offers.
Once the terms are approved, someone has to make sure the letter says exactly those terms and nothing more. SHRM's reporting on rescinded offers collects the standard warnings. If at-will employment is intended, the letter should state it clearly and avoid language that reads like a promise of a set term or future compensation, because a letter worded like a contract can be treated like one. Any conditions — a background check, a drug test, eligibility verification — should be written into the letter as conditions, and the applicant should sign a copy showing they understood them; if an offer later has to be withdrawn, that signed page is the documented support that the candidate accepted the possibility. SHRM's interview guidance on offers adds the operational traps: no oral promises outside the written offer, and one point of contact for the candidate, so that managers who met the candidate during interviews do not make casual commitments that HR then has to unwind.
At senior levels this gate changes shape. SHRM's offer guidance notes legal counsel typically reviews offers at senior manager level and above, with severance terms getting the closest attention, because that is where a single clause can commit a small or midsize company to serious money.
What bounces it back: contract-like wording, conditions mentioned in conversation but missing from the letter, or nonstandard terms — severance, noncompete, relocation — that have not had legal eyes on them. The paper trail is the reviewed, version-controlled letter itself.

Handoff six: the verbal offer
Owner: the recruiter or hiring manager — one named person, by design.
Only now does the candidate hear anything. The verbal offer comes first, and the negotiation, if there is one, happens here, before anything is put in writing. SHRM's offer guidance is blunt about why: settle the terms in conversation, then duplicate the agreed terms in the written offer. If the candidate counteroffers on pay or start date, the changed terms travel back through handoffs three and four — compensation check and budget sign-off — at least in abbreviated form, because the approval was granted for specific numbers, not for a range of outcomes the approvers never saw.
What bounces it back: a counteroffer above the approved ceiling, which returns to HR and finance rather than being conceded on the phone. The paper trail is a dated note of the verbal offer and the candidate's response, kept in the candidate record.
Handoff seven: the written offer and its conditions
Owner: HR, issuing the letter and running the post-offer checks.
The written offer goes out with the agreed terms, the conditions stated in the letter, and a deadline to respond. The candidate signs — SHRM's sources advise requiring a signed copy indicating the candidate understood the conditions. Then the conditions themselves run, and this is where jurisdiction takes over the workflow. Under the federal Fair Credit Reporting Act, an employer using a third-party background check must give a stand-alone disclosure and get the candidate's written authorization first; if the report leads the employer toward withdrawing the offer, the candidate must receive a pre-adverse action notice with a copy of the report and the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau's summary of rights, and then an adverse action notice after the decision. Some jurisdictions add more: SHRM's California guidance explains that California employers generally must wait until after a conditional offer to ask about criminal history, run an individualized assessment if a conviction surfaces, and follow state notice steps on top of the federal ones — and California requires its own separate disclosure as well. Other states and cities set their own sequencing and notice rules, so the order of operations in this final stage is the one part of the workflow that cannot be copied from another employer's template. Pay transparency and salary-history rules vary the same way, changing what the letter and the posting may say from one location to the next.
What bounces it back: a failed condition, handled through whatever notice sequence the applicable law requires — and SHRM's rescission guidance adds that withdrawing an offer should get a full legal review before the candidate is contacted, because a candidate who has resigned a job or relocated in reliance on the offer can claim damages under promissory estoppel even without a signed contract. The paper trail is the signed offer, the authorizations, the check results, and copies of every notice sent.
The file, complete
When the chain works, what exists at the end is not a letter but a file: an approved requisition the offer can be traced to; a decision note written when the decision was made; a compensation check showing the band and the figure's place in it; a dated budget approval; a reviewed letter with its conditions spelled out and a signed copy back from the candidate; a note of the verbal offer and any counteroffer's re-approval; and the consent forms and notices the post-offer checks required. Every stage had one owner, one question it existed to answer, and one artefact it left behind. That is the whole workflow — and it is also why offers that skip the chain tend to fail in the same places: the stage that was skipped is usually the one whose question nobody else was asking.
Sources
- SHRM, "Tips for Making Confident Job Offers" — https://www.shrm.org/topics-tools/news/talent-acquisition/tips-making-confident-job-offers — supports: the offer initiates the legal employment relationship; what an offer should spell out (compensation, benefits, title, terms, items to sign before starting); the salary and benefits package being decided early in the process, often when the need for the position is determined; offers staying within company limits and fair practices; negotiating verbally before producing the written offer; legal counsel reviewing offers at senior manager level and above, with attention to severance; the pitfalls of oral promises outside the written offer and the need for one point of contact.
- SHRM, "Beware: Rescinding Job Offers Can Prompt Legal Consequences" — https://www.shrm.org/topics-tools/news/talent-acquisition/beware-rescinding-job-offers-can-prompt-legal-consequences — supports: promissory estoppel risk when a candidate relies on an offer; offer letters stating at-will employment clearly and avoiding language that promises a term or future compensation; letters stating conditions precedent clearly and requiring the applicant to sign a copy indicating understanding; legal review before an offer is rescinded; federal, state and local notification requirements when an offer is withdrawn over a failed condition such as a background check.
- SHRM, "Confused About Background Checks in California? Read This" — https://www.shrm.org/topics-tools/news/talent-acquisition/confused-background-checks-california-read — supports: FCRA stand-alone disclosure and written consent before a consumer report is obtained, with a separate California disclosure; pre-adverse action notice including a copy of the report and the CFPB summary of rights, followed by an adverse action notice; California's rule against inquiring into criminal history until after a conditional offer; the individualized assessment and state notice steps for conviction history; state and local laws layering additional obligations on top of federal law.
- US Office of Personnel Management, "Request for Personnel Action to Fill the Job" (Hiring Process Analysis Tool) — https://www.opm.gov/policy-data-oversight/human-capital-management/hiring-reform/hiring-process-analysis-tool/request-for-personnel-action-to-fill-the-job/ — supports: the federal model in which the manager creates the Request for Personnel Action (SF-52) to fill the position and obtains approval of it as an early, gated step in the hiring process.
Run this on your own hiring data
A six-week recruiting pilot measures exactly these things — parser accuracy, reviewer agreement, time per application and compliance records — on your role family, with your reviewers, before you decide anything.